(Reuters) - China wants to elbow oil giant Exxon Mobil out of a $15 billion liquefied natural gas (LNG) project in Papua New Guinea, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said on Wednesday in an example of the new competition Beijing presents to U.S. interests.
Clinton told the Senate Foreign Relations Committee that Republican proposals to cut the U.S. foreign affairs budget would hit U.S. efforts to compete with China's rising power on the global stage.
"We are in a competition with China," Clinton said, citing the Papua New Guinea energy find as an example.
"Exxon Mobil is producing it. China is in there every day, in every way, trying to figure out how its going to come in behind us, come in under us," she said.
Exxon Mobil is the majority stakeholder in the Papua New Guinea project, which is due to come on stream in 2014 and is expected to produce 6.6 million tonnes of LNG per year -- a potential windfall for the poor island nation.
Clinton said China was also boosting ties with other states across the Asia-Pacific, including what she called the "dictatorial regime" in Fiji and other island nations that have long been reliable if little noticed U.S. allies.
Clinton said funding cuts that would require a U.S. pullback on everything from support for global health programs to protection of women's rights could have a serious long-term impact on U.S. influence around the world.
"If anybody thinks that our retreating on these issues is somehow going to be irrelevant to the maintenance of our leadership in a world where we are competing with China, where we are competing with Iran, that is a mistaken notion," she said.
Republicans have proposed a 16 percent cut to U.S. spending on diplomacy and foreign assistance, among other things, saying it is imperative to fight the ballooning federal deficit.
Clinton said the U.S. retreat was opening new doors to competitors, noting new media challengers such as Al Jazeera and Russian and Chinese English-language broadcasters were winning "the information war".
"Let's put aside the moral, humanitarian do-good side of what we believe in and let's just talk straight realpolitik," Clinton said of the various U.S. programs that could be hit by the budget cuts.
"I also look at this from a strategic perspective, and it is essential."
Thursday, 3 March 2011
Friday, 4 February 2011
Post Courier Reports (3/2/11) Second LNG PNG Gets Thumbs Up
By Mohammad Bashir
Papua New Guinea's second LNG project which is expected to bigger and expected to produce 11 to 15 million tones got a step closer yesterday witnessed by Prime Minister sir Michael Somare, Treaurer and Finance Minister Peter O'Neill, Petroleum and Energy Minister William Duma, Gulf Governor Havilla Kavo and Police Minister Mark Maipaka and industry executives.
Pacific LNG Operations Ltd witnessed Liquid Niugini Gas Ltd, its Joint-Venture liquefied natural gas project company with InterOil sign a Project Funding and Construction Agreement (PFCA) and a Shareholders Agreement with Energy World Corporation Ltd. (AX: EWC) to construct a three million tonne per annum (mtpa) land-based LNG plant in the Gulf Province of Papua New Guinea (PNG), which is developed in two places, 2mtpa and 1mtpa expansion following immediately thereafter.
The agreement follow Pacific LNG Operations Ltd, September 2010 announcement of the formation of the partnership with EWC.
The Train 1 LNG plant would process an estimated 2.25 trillion cubic feet (Tcf) of natural gas over 15 years. In return for its commitment to fully fund the plant, the agreements provide that EWC is entitled to a fee of 14.5% of the proceeds from the sale of LNG from the plant, less agreed deductions, and subject to adjustments based on timing and execution. The Train 1 LNG project with EWC for the development of a modular LNG plant is designed to take gas from the proposed condensate stripping plant (CSP) being pursued in joint venture with Mitsui and accelerate the intended monetization of the Elk and Antelope resource, while eliminating the need for gas re-injecction into reservoir. The agreements provide a framework for the possible expansion of the plant's capacity to 8 mtpa of LNG. Henry Aldorf, President of Pacific LNG Operations Ltd, said
"These agreements signed today with EWC will enable Liquid Niugini Gas to have their LNG plants to be built economically compared with other new LNG Projects and provide LNG to the Asian market in a record time. As a result, I expect that the classical LNG project development approach will be changed by this modular LNG plant model as it will allow the economic development of LNG and provide reliable, clean and green energy to Asia."
The PFCA and Shareholder Agreements with EWC are conditional reaching FID no later than 31 December 2011. However, as previously disclosed the current joint venture project schedule is for FID to occur simultaneously for the LNG plant and CSP by June 30, 2011 and combined plant start up approximately 30 months after FID. This now adds blessing to the already arranged agreement between Gulf Provincial Government and Energy International to have a Petroleum Park established at Orokolo bay in Ihu District Gulf Province. InterOil's Senior Public Relations Manager Susuve Laumaea said they hope to get their Petroleum Development licence in March or before next year.
He confirmed that InterOil would be processing and stripping all LNG products in Gulf Province and would not need to pipe it to its Napa Napa Refinery.
Monday, 31 January 2011
Exxon Made Us Do It: Sam Passes the Buck
LNGWATCH PNG: They say that patriotism is the scoundrel’s last refuge, perhaps in this case it is foreign companies. Stop passing the buck DPM Abal, Exxon can only do to PNG what your government allows them to do.
Source:
The National - Monday, January 31, 2011
By PATRICK TALU
THE government has admitted to resource owners and the people of Papua New Guinea that the PNG liquefied natural gas project agreement signing was rushed.
Newly appointed minister responsible for all LNG matters relating to outstanding memorandum of agreements (MoA), ministerial commitments, seed capital finds, infrastructure development grants and other outstanding issues, Deputy Prime Minister Sam Abal, made the admittance last Friday to landowners at the Unagi oval in Port Moresby.
“Mipela government i tok sori long rasim PNG LNG agreement mipela i sainim (we, in government, are sorry for the rushed PNG LNG agreement that was signed),” Abal said.
He said there was immense pressure to get the project to first gas within limited time to secure markets against competing LNG projects in the region.
The window of opportunity for PNG’s gas to secure lucrative markets would have closed had PNG taken longer to bring the project on stream.
Abal said due to these pressures, the government had no choice but to conform to the will of the developer and entered into the PNG LNG agreement.
He admitted that the current LNG-related issue between the government, ExxonMobil and the landowners was the direct outcome of that rushed agreement.
The deputy prime minister, who is also minister for works and MP for Wabag, stressed that since the mistake was already made, there was no option but to address the consequences.
Thomas Gamu, the man who had been mobilising LNG project landowners to fight for their rights and benefits, asked Abal how they would be compensated.
“Now that the LNG agreement has been rushed and cheaply sold away, the government must tell us as resource owners, Hela, and the people of PNG how we will be compensated for selling our gas cheaply.
“Our resource has been cheaply and hastily sold off by our government.
“It is a great failure on the part of the government to protect its interest and its sovereignty than serving the interest of foreign-owned
Public reactions to recent troubles at LNG PNG
Source:
The National- Friday, January 28, 2011
I REFER to your article, “LNG plant will stay shut” (The National, Jan 25).
It clearly pointed out that police were involved in confrontations, and perhaps, brutality of a civilian which could have resulted in death.
It clearly pointed out that police were involved in confrontations, and perhaps, brutality of a civilian which could have resulted in death.
The government had ordered more police to the area to maintain peace and stability among frustrated relatives of the deceased of a previous incident over possible chemical poisoning.
It looks like the situation would get out of hand if a compromise is not reached among all respective parties.
One major threat of a possible civil war that the government of the day should take into consideration is the fact that what has transpired in Bougainville years ago can erupt again up in the Southern Highlands.
It’s like a time bomb ready to go off.
Facts to enlighten us are:
Facts to enlighten us are:
(1) It was the mobile unit that initially started the war in Bougainville which resulted in a very dark historical page for PNG; and
(2) It always resulted in the government committing itself to the developer ahead of sorting out outstanding landing owner issues, hence a war on Panguna.
The potential for an even bigger war than Bougainville is here.
(2) It always resulted in the government committing itself to the developer ahead of sorting out outstanding landing owner issues, hence a war on Panguna.
The potential for an even bigger war than Bougainville is here.
To date, the government has not completely addressed the firearm issues in the Highlands region.
What guarantee does it have to offer the people that it can forcefully bring in peace and stability through the use of its law enforcing agency?
It’s your call PM.
Gideon Maim
Via email
= = = == = == = ==== = =====
It’s your call PM.
Gideon Maim
Via email
= = = == = == = ==== = =====
Source:
The National- Friday, January 28, 2011
THE court will need to exercise sensitivity to find a way forward for all so-called landowner disputes over the PNG LNG project development and benefits sharing promised by the government under the UBSA/LBBSA.
The PNG LNG project, driven by Esso Highlands and PNG government, will likely to be jeopardised because of the insensitivity of the judicial system in entertaining so-called landowners’ disputes over range of landownership, legitimacy, rights, benefits in the light of the umbrella benefit sharing agreements (UBSA) and landowner-based benefits sharing agreements (LBBSA), among others, to cloud the outstanding issues under the oil regime.
The importance of the project and the potential benefits it will deliver will not be realised if the court system is insensitive to unwinding specific issues.
The issues under the oil regime should not be mixed with the gas regime in terms of outstanding MOAs, IBD grants and government/ministerial commitments.
The issues under the oil regime should not be mixed with the gas regime in terms of outstanding MOAs, IBD grants and government/ministerial commitments.
Some landowners are still disputing the UBSAs/LBBSAs/ where the notion of majority rules in a decision to an agreement. Some are disputing the ministerial determination.
In some cases, some elite proxy landowners have immensely siphoned off benefits in the oil regime and therefore the illiterate owners are making their way to Port Moresby to stop the same abuse on the gas resource benefits and so on.
Others who have missed out are disputing that payments were made to the wrong company within the licensed area or project foot print as per the provision of UBSA.
Others who have missed out are disputing that payments were made to the wrong company within the licensed area or project foot print as per the provision of UBSA.
Landowner representatives have been given some sort of power of attorney by their people to negotiate the UBSAs/LBBSAs and secure benefits for them in their respective project licensed areas.
The business development grant was one of the benefits to be made available for the landowners in the project foot print to be given in a form of seed capital to participate in the spin-off activities during the early works phase which started last year.
Some who had been given these responsibilities have abused by not keeping their own people informed of the grants paid to them.
Hence, they have been labelled “paper landowners” in Port Moresby while others have been taken to the courts to prevent them accessing the grants.
If they wait for the social mapping which will start next month, they would miss 30 % of the opportunity remaining in the early works spin off minor contracts.
Plant site landowner
Via email
If they wait for the social mapping which will start next month, they would miss 30 % of the opportunity remaining in the early works spin off minor contracts.
Plant site landowner
Via email
= = = = = = = = = = = = == = = = = =
Source:
The National- Friday, January 28, 2011
WHEN the PNG LNG deal was first signed between the government, landowners, financiers and the developers, the government gave security concerns top priority, or was it just interested in the billion bucks that was to be earned from the deal.
The security aspects involving such a multi-billion-dollar project is of a paramount importance, especially when the projects areas are located in more volatile area, it must be a top agenda by any government of the day when negotiating with stakeholders concerned.
Does the government employ security consultants or advisors and if it so, did they give the right advice to the government about sensitive landowner issues within the mine and projects sites located all over PNG?
It seems like we have not learnt yet from the Bougainville crisis and the government must envisage the future and be guided by the Bougainville scenario prior to arising to any project agreement.
We must always bear in mind that different ethnic groups have their own languages, cultures and behaviour therefore behave in their own different ways.
The government must ensure that every one’s interests within the project areas are considered prior to kick start any projects.
Steven Supi Palisa
Boroko
= = = = = = = == = = =
Source:
The National- Friday, January 28, 2011
THE uncalled attack on the employees of the Clough Curtain Joint Venture at the LNG plant site recently must be condemned with the harshest terms there is.
There are avenues available to address such issues.
There are avenues available to address such issues.
The blame should have gone to the parents and guardians of the deceased for negligence than to anyone else.
It is bewildering to read of 700 hundred moaning relatives attacking the LNG plant site, when not one of those concerned 700-plus bothered to spare sometime to watch the boy as he roamed unattended into a billion dollar chemical plant construction site that fateful day.
I have read of such hideous episodes in many of PNG’s history and I am ashamed deeply to see it conjure up again in the21st century.
I wonder if any of those 700 relatives have hear of the word “autopsy” to determine cause of death
Fumbruk Erike
Via email
Fumbruk Erike
Via email
Thursday, 27 January 2011
Don't Bank the Billions Just Yet
Sadly, the game begins! Last October LNGWATCH wrote: "Given that Exxon Mobil will be operating in a highly contested region, where their operations will come under threat from landowner protests, will they be able to responsibly control the security agencies protecting their operations ... Will Exxon Mobil [Esso Highlands parent] accept assistance from a paramilitary force (i.e. the Mobile Squads) with a sustained history of human rights abuses?". Of course, no response was ever given to these questions.
Now that villagers living near the LNG project have staged direction action protests, that have left Esso Highlands employees with minor injuries (of course, it is in the interests of Esso to play down the event, danger = higher labour costs), these issues are back on the cards in a very big way.
It appears that staff in the affected areas have been withdrawn. Esso Highlands' public relations manager has told the Post Courier: “The shutdown will continue until the safety and security of project personnel can be assured”.
This is what we might call a corporate euphemism. What Esso Highlands are asking for is more support from the mobile squads, or some national force that can protect their operation, supplemented by increased ministerial attention to landowner grievances.
Thus, over the coming weeks more mobile squad officers will no doubt be dispatched to affected regions to protect Esso Highlands' operations. The Somare government will also most likely announce a new initiative of some variety to resolve existing tensions.
Though in real terms, Esso Highland's request for assurances is unrealistic. For some in the Southern Highlands they are an unwanted exploiter, for others they are a welcomed but distrusted guest, who must offer serious benefits. With executives and government officials clearly overwhelmed by the complexity of the social systems they are dealing with, tensions will explode again, that is a certainty. In such an environment safety cannot be assured, especially if we take into account virulent arms circulation and the rugged terrain which punctuates the operation.
Consequently, over the coming months Esso Highlands and their parent company Exxon Mobil will need to innovate. There is no Indonesian style military in Papua New Guinea to force consent, despite the well documented authoritarian aspirations of Somare and co. Perhaps attention is being turned to a Sandline International, who can send in ex-special force troops from the US, Britain, Australia and elsewhere to install 'a bit of order' in the local communites. However, a more offensive use of private security forces would seem unlikely under present conditions.
Most likely enhanced strategies to win the peoples’ hearts and minds will be employed. However, when your objective is to make billions of dollars in profit in a context where local villagers live several days walk from basic medical attention, disparities in wealth and dislocation of culture, may be too palpable for any innovation to withstand.
Of course, those in the oil, gas and minerals industry will cry, “what’s the alternative”. For them profit, plunder, and growth fuelled by big capital, are sacred and unquestionable truths. In their eyes, there is no ‘realistic’ alternative to it. This is the mantra of modern day missionaries come to spread the word of neoliberalism, they are zealots for a social system that has undermined communities around Papua New Guinea for decades, while fuelling a state system beleaguered by corruption and cronyism.
Alternatives, of course, exist but it is often difficult for community leaders and activists promoting them to have their voices heard when the majestic prophecies of wealth and economic growth elicited by the elite and their intellectual cadre is so loudly trumpeted in the press and parliament. There are also very real risks associated with dissent at present in Papua New Guinea, especially when money is to be made, as the recent litigation over Ramu Nickel illustrates. Indeed the risk of beatings or worse now seems part of the course for those offering alternative solutions to the elite.
Meanwhile villagers in the Southern Highlands will do their best under extreme conditions to observe an oft forgotten constitutional duty: "We declare our first goal to be for every person to be dynamically involved in the process of freeing himself or herself from every form of domination or oppression so that each man or woman will have the opportunity to develop as a whole person in relationship with others".
Tuesday, 25 January 2011
Government "willing to take harsh measures" to ensure LNG's security?
LNGWATCH PNG: Global Insights (25/01/2011) predict in the following report that the PNG government are willing to take harsh measures to put down local protests against the LNG.
PNG Government Launches Investigation Into LNG Attack
By Neil Ashdown
The government of Papua New Guinea (PNG) has launched a high-level investigation into an attack that led to the closure of a key site in the ExxonMobil LNG project. On 21 January there was an attack on the Hides 4 LNG conditioning plant site in Southern Highlands province. Estimates of the number of people involved vary, but the police said the number was around 200. The attack led to the evacuation of workers from the site. While order has now been restored at the site and the police presence has been reinforced, ExxonMobil today announced that the site will remain closed until the security of its personnel can be assured. The government and ExxonMobil have denied the attack caused serious injuries, with the latter claiming that four workers were treated for minor injuries at the site. The 21 January attack affected the same project that last week was the target of peaceful protests by landowners. It has been reported that the violence was sparked by the death of a four-year-old child, with locals believing that his death was related to the LNG project.
The team conducting the investigation is being led by Don Polye, a former deputy prime minister who is now foreign minister. It also includes the treasury and energy ministers, William Duma and Peter O'Neill, and Tony Wagambie, the acting police commissioner. Indicating the government's priorities, Polye has stated that the team's objective is for the immediate resumption of work at the site while negotiations take place to find a remedy for the landowners' grievances.
Significance:The seniority of the team conducting the investigation is evidence of how seriously the government takes this attack. The LNG project is at the centre of its economic policy and the government would be willing to take harsh measures to ensure its security. However, in doing so it risks alienating the local population and increasing the chance of further incidents.
ExxonMobil: LNG plant will stay shut
LNGWATCH PNG: Exxon operate in some pretty 'rough and ready' places across the world. This violence will not overly phase them. However, internally within Exxon questions may be being raised over the competence of the Police Commissioner and/or senior Ministers. Besides resolving the issue so they can get on with what they are there for, making money, Exxon will be concerned about minimizing publicity over the attacks on employees. Bad press will potentially frighten off expatriate staff, and may lead to employee’s asking for ‘danger money’. Esso Highland's PR man Miles Shaw, if he is a smart operator, has most likely developed a good relationship with key journalists to ensure 'the facts' are reported, i.e. Esso/Exxon's preferred version of events.
The National- Tuesday, January 25, 2011
By PATRICK TALU
EXXONMOBIL Corp, operator of the multi-billion-kina PNG liquefied natural gas project, said the Hides 4 LNG conditioning plant site will remain shut.
ExxonMobil’s subsidiary Esso Highlands Ltd public affairs manager Miles Shaw yesterday said “as a result of this illegal action, we are instituting a shutdown at the Hides gas conditioning plant site”.
ExxonMobil’s subsidiary Esso Highlands Ltd public affairs manager Miles Shaw yesterday said “as a result of this illegal action, we are instituting a shutdown at the Hides gas conditioning plant site”.
Shaw said during the shutdown, the company would “discuss the necessity of a safe and secure operating environment with the government and local leaders and the requirement to use established processes in place to manage any dispute”.
“Any use of violence is unacceptable,” he added.
Miles also confirmed that a group of people illegally entered the project camp at Hides 4 petroleum development licence (PDL) 7 last Friday evening and allegedly attacked four workers who sustained minor injuries.
In related events, members of a mobile police unit stationed at Hides 4 last Saturday allegedly beat a man in relation to last Friday night’s event.
Miles also confirmed that a group of people illegally entered the project camp at Hides 4 petroleum development licence (PDL) 7 last Friday evening and allegedly attacked four workers who sustained minor injuries.
In related events, members of a mobile police unit stationed at Hides 4 last Saturday allegedly beat a man in relation to last Friday night’s event.
The man was said to have died from his injuries, causing more fear among workers that relatives would retaliate.
A government ministerial delegation was expected to fly into the area today.
Acting Police Commissioner Tony Wagambie said last night more police personnel would be sent to the area today (see reports on Page 3).
The national planning committee, chaired by Deputy Prime Minister Sam Abal, would be briefed by the company today.
Foreign Affairs, Trade and Immigration Minister Don Polye said in a statement yesterday that he had been tasked by the prime minister to lead a fact-finding mission to the plant site today.
Polye said his objective was to negotiate for the immediate resumption of work at the project site while talks continue among all parties to find a lasting solution to the issues raised by the landowners as well as other stakeholders in the project.
Polye would be accompanied by Petroleum and Energy Minister William Duma and Treasurer Peter O’Neill.
Polye would be accompanied by Petroleum and Energy Minister William Duma and Treasurer Peter O’Neill.
Southern Highlands Governor Anderson Agiru said yesterday that the government needed to get its house in order and that it was part of the problem.
Too many ministers were responsible for different aspects of the project and for payments to the people, which was creating confusion among the people, he said.
Agiru said the government must appoint one person to liaise with the people and project developers. He recommended Abal.
Too many ministers were responsible for different aspects of the project and for payments to the people, which was creating confusion among the people, he said.
Agiru said the government must appoint one person to liaise with the people and project developers. He recommended Abal.
Today’s national planning committee meeting would focus on the ExxonMobil matter as well as unbudgeted commitments by the ministers.
Friday night’s intruders were removed by police while all personnel in the construction camp had been accounted for.
Miles told The National that there was no damage to the camp facilities and equipment.
Friday night’s intruders were removed by police while all personnel in the construction camp had been accounted for.
Miles told The National that there was no damage to the camp facilities and equipment.
“The motivation for the invasion remains unclear; however, local village leaders have apologised.
“Police have initiated an investigation and we are providing our full support,” Miles added.
The initial shutdown occurred last Friday over the death of a four-year-old boy who allegedly consumed a powder-like substance used for drill blast at a quarry site near Hides 4.
Sources claimed angry relatives demanded that CCJV, contractor of the LNG plant site, accept liability. When this failed, the villagers allegedly forced their way into the camp and stopped all work.
Sources claimed angry relatives demanded that CCJV, contractor of the LNG plant site, accept liability. When this failed, the villagers allegedly forced their way into the camp and stopped all work.
Meanwhile, attempts to contact Gigira Hides 4 Joint Venture chairman Erick Ayule and other leaders were unsuccessful.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)